| Dylan Rogers | Air Force | 2021 |  |
| Cam Bonds | Regis College | 2021 |  |
| Casey Workman | Hill College | 2021 | |
| Dylan Stowe | Wayland Baptist | 2021 | |
| Reid Lapekas | Vassar | 2020 |  |
| Mason Andrews | Colorado School of the Mines | 2020 |  |
| Sean Mansour | Grayson | 2020 |  |
| Ethan Perry | Henderson State | 2020 |  |
| Zack Garza | Trinity University | 2020 |  |
| Cameron Constantine | University of Texas | 2019 |  |
| Isaiah Rhodes | Southern Miss | 2019 |  |
| Ezra Gore | Trinity University | 2019 |  |
| Caden Bonds | Colorado School of the Mines | 2018 |  |
| Grant Lake | Oklahoma Christian | 2018 |  |
| Jack Gee | Texas Tech | 2018 |  |
| Jared McClain | Grayson College | 2018 |  |
| Conner Fiene | Wayne State College | 2017 |  |
| AJ Vonderschmidt | Corker College | 2017 |  |
| Elijah Valdez | Hill College | 2017 |  |
| Tyler Reiter | East Texas Baptist | 2017 |  |
| Tyler Gatewood | Northwestern State | 2017 |  |
| Carter Camp | West Virginia | 2016 |  |
| Ty Sawka | University of Texas Arlington | 2016 | 
|
| Tyler Blomster | Colorado School of the Mines | 2016 | 
|
| Gabe Constantine | Wichita State/Grayson College | 2015 | 
|
| Luke Bay | Paris JC / Kansas State | 2015 | 
|
| Preston Spears | Ouachita Baptist University | 2015 | 
|
| Jacob Faubion | LeTourneau University | 2015 | 
|
| Nate Dobbie | Dallas Christian College | 2015 | 
|
| Montana Sadler | Grayson College | 2014 |  |
| Alex Dobbie | Dallas Christian College | 2014 | 
|
| JT Stevens | East Central University | 2013 |  |
| Anthony Herrera | University of Louisiana-Monroe | 2013 |  |
| Heath Beasley | Abilene Christian University | 2012 | 
|
| Braden Fair | Oklahoma Christian College | 2012 |  |
| Aaron Rhodes | Texas A&M Corpus | 2012 |  |
| Grant Michalak | Hardin Simmons | 2012 |  |
| Will Shumate | Murray State | 2012 |  |
| Kendle Ladd | Universtiy of Oklahoma | 2010 |  |
| AJ Florence | Texas Tech / OCC | 2010 |  |
| Ty Crump | Tarleton State | 2010 |  |
| Zach Diaz | Dallas Christian College | 2009 |  |
| Justin Scharf | TCU | 2009 |  |
| Austin Schuler | UMSL | 2008 |  |
| Trey Sorells | South Alabama Universtiy | 2008 |  |
| Nico Taylor | Northwood U / Toronto Bluejays | 2008 |  |
| Garrett Yates | Northwood University | 2008 |  |
| Trent Appleby | TCU | 2007 |  |
| Erik Ross | Oklahoma University | 2007 |  |
| Cruz Garcia | Brookhaven | 2007 |  |
| Andrew Smith | Texas Tech | 2007 |  |
| Tyler Steed | Austin College | 2007 |  |
| Mike Bolsinger | Arkansas/Az Diamonback/LA Dodgers/Toronto Bluejays | 2006 |  |
| Drew Hanish | University of Minnesota | 2006 |  |
| Michael Reed | Texas Tech | 2006 |  |
| TJ Ladd | Southeastern Oklahoma | 2005 |  |
| Jessie Lasiter | Southern Illinois | 2005 |  |
| Jordan Torr | Arkansa State | 2005 |  |
| Michael Gunter | NCTCC/Angelo State | 2004 |  |
| Alex Burris | Panola College | 2004 |  |